Doomed from the beginning - Wouldn't Like to Disclose SHINE Technologies Employee Review

1.0
Feb 6, 2024
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I learned a lot about my field. I gained valuable leadership and management experience. Hard-earned but necessary cynicism about the motives of executives.

Cons

It all starts and ends with the executive management team. To say that the executive team is out-of-touch with the rank and file is a massive understatement. The leadership team have consistently mismanaged resources and now they've run out of money. For a long time there was no contract management or vendor management to speak of, leading to huge costs and delays. Until the last couple years the CEO was skeptical that Project Management was even a profession, so engineers were forced to be their own project managers, with predictable consequences. A healthy skepticism on the part of the CEO about the inertia of the nuclear industry warped over time into a pathological distrust of experience in general. When experienced people made it through the hiring process and questioned the base engineering or scientific assumptions undergirding the project, they didn't last long at the company. They weren't "a good culture fit." The upshot of all this mismanagement and lack of experience was that a first of its kind, cutting-edge medical isotopes plant was mostly designed by inexperienced junior engineers without experienced oversight or mentorship. They designed without sufficient resources and working to an unrealistic timeline sold to investors. Once construction started, the work was barely keeping ahead of final design. No one should have been surprised when the project became hopelessly behind schedule and over budget. As things spiraled out of control, panic set in and the blame game started. It was the pandemic, it was work from home, the staff are lazy; everything was wrong as long as it didn't hold a mirror to the executive team's own behavior. Expensive executive management consultants came through, but nothing changed. The board should have replaced the CEO years ago, once it became clear that the project was failing. Instead, senior leadership became paranoid and shifted blame to the workers instead of reckoning with their own failures. The culture quickly became toxic and paranoid. What had been an admirably flexible work culture evaporated as the executives started equating productivity with the amount of time people sat at their desk in the office. When the layoffs finally came in August 2023, none of the people actually responsible for the failures was let go. No consequences for them, but a lot of good people who believed in the project lost their jobs. The moly plant project is basically mothballed. Several hundred million dollars worth of building is collecting dust because they don't have the resources to redesign all the components that didn't work. Instead, the company is trying to convert their Therapeutics R&D process into a commercial product on a timeline that is, wait for it, hopelessly optimistic in a bid to bring the company to solvency. Add in a "Phase 3" project for which there is no actual business case and you come to the sobering realization that the company's much-touted "sustainable path to fusion" is a stillborn joke. Frankly, if you need to deceive investors with an overly rosy budget and timeline in order to obtain funding, was there ever really a business case in the first place?

avatar
SHINE Technologies Response
2y
Thank you for sharing your feedback on your experience at SHINE. Building a first-of-its-kind company with an ambitious vision like ours is challenging. It requires constant adaptation and innovation to drive progress in markets and technologies. While you may perceive certain outcomes as failures, from our perspective, they represent strategic decisions made in response to evolving market dynamics. Our decisions are guided by a focus on achieving success amid challenging market conditions and long-term projects. We respectfully refrain from commenting on hearsay. Our focus remains on objective facts and evidence-based assessments. The best proof of our success is our long-term and committed customer base in imaging, the commercial launch of the biggest lutetium-177 facility in North America in less than a year, and a new radiation effects testing business serving a market need with fusion. We are proud of the significant milestones we've accomplished, many of which of which have broken new ground in the industries we serve. Again, thank you for taking the time to write. We sincerely wish you well on your endeavors.

Explore other reviews about SHINE Technologies

5.0
Jun 1, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

High quality team. Extremely interesting projects.

Cons

Depending on the role, you may have to travel between the Janesville and Madison offices.

5.0
Mar 15, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

SHINE is a great place to work. PEOPLE: A lot of focus is put on finding the right people. After working close to 30 years in a variety of industrial environments, I can say that SHINE does a great job of hiring great people. The culture here is one of teamwork and grit; I have yet to come across someone that wasn’t willing to go out of their way to help their teammates. It’s a very collaborative environment. After working in numerous other sectors, I’d say the culture at SHINE has been my favorite balance of doing the right thing and still having fun while doing hard and important work. The opportunity for growth here is a huge plus. If you work hard, do the right thing, innovate and communicate, you will succeed. In a company that is growing as fast as SHINE, you will find the opportunity to grow and develop, especially if you are new to your field or the industry. This sets SHINE apart from so many other places I’ve worked in my career; this opportunity can’t be overstated, if you are looking for somewhere to grow, this is it! The atmosphere is flexible; you’re given the space to get the job done and treated like a professional. MISSION: SHINE is simultaneously manufacturing lifesaving Lu-177 while performing fusion R&D. We’re implementing new technologies and new techniques. It’s truly gratifying to come to work with the knowledge that we make something that saves lives. The research and work we do is cutting edge. We interface with peers across a number of sectors and not only is what we do on the cutting edge, but how we do it is right there as well. The culture here breeds innovation, and frankly that atmosphere is part of what makes working here so gratifying. With the recent addition of the SPECT side of the business at the end of 2025, a continual striving for our share of the Lu-177 market, and the refocus on our main production facility, there has never been a more exciting time to be part of SHINE!

Cons

It’s not always easy working at a company in its early stages of production, but the pros vastly outweigh the cons, and honesty the cons just feed into the pros. It is certainly a fast-paced environment. Because of what we do and where we are in our journey, we sometimes need to pivot priorities. This can be frustrating for some folks; it adds to the challenge for sure but navigating through these challenges with the team is part of what makes working here gratifying. This isn’t a place that’s been doing the same thing for 50 years; don’t expect to find everything laid out for you when you get here. We’re building the future, the processes, the systems; this takes time and the road isn’t always smooth, but that’s part of the package. SHINE manages safety and risk in an appropriate manner. You can’t innovate without challenging the status quo. SHINE is in a different place operationally and financially at this stage. Some of the more thoughtful reviews from past years touch on where we were. The more negative reviews are unfortunate; a handful of them are clearly disgruntled folks with an ax to grind. The more thoughtful criticisms speak to previous challenges at SHINE. We’ve been in some tough spots, but more due to external market challenges in my opinion. Turnover was a problem for a bit, but this has turned around, a very encouraging sign/metric that we’re heading in the right direction.

1
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All