employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

Books-A-Million

Is this your company?

Books-A-Million reviews

3.3

58% would recommend to a friend

(1,746 total reviews)

Terry Finley

61% approve of CEO

48% positive business outlook

Books-A-Million has an employee rating of 3.3 out of 5 stars, based on 1,746 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Books-A-Million employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Retail & Wholesale industry (3.5 stars).

Reviews by job title

2K reviews
2.0
Aug 3, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Book check-out program, employee discount, work with fellow book lovers, get paid to hang out in a bookstore all day!

Cons

Non-stop pressure to meet metrics. Even if you bang out an awesome week one week, it resets on Sunday and the pressure is on all over again. Hours are all over the place - I worked as an AGM in one store and a co-manager in another and never had a 'regular' schedule. Frequently closed one night and had to turn around and open the following morning. At one of the stores I worked at, the schedule was CONSTANTLY "subject to change" without notice, forcing employees to constantly recheck the schedule and potentially rearrange their plans outside of work. Really crappy pay; even as an AGM, my salary after all the extra hours I frequently had to work was barely above minimum wage. There are no raises for anyone but the GM, and even that raise is a joke. As are the "bonuses!" Each quarter, the management team gets a bonus that is a percentage of the store's overall sales. But that percentage can be reduced for a number of different reasons, many of which you have zero control over, and you lose the entire bonus altogether if you fail to make any single one of the metrics. And when you do get a bonus, it's a joke - my most recent bonus as AGM was a whole $60 for the quarter. Talk about feeling underappreciated. One of the perks of the job is supposed to be Spiff, which is extra money you get when you sell a membership card, get that member to sign up for an auto-renewal, or sign someone up for magazines. BUT the amount you get is pretty insignificant (the most I ever received was less than $20 for the week, and that was with the Stellar Seller double bonus) and you lose out completely if the rest of the store doesn't make it. I have experienced this frustration myself and seen it in many of my employees, who work our butts off to try and make good numbers but get no compensation for it because some other team members struggle. There is a LOT of trickle-down stress in this company. At one of the stores I worked at, the DM was really fantastic and even though she rode us constantly about our metrics, we knew it was because she was getting it from above her. At my second store, the managers were treating the staff so horribly over numbers that when I told a cashier who was getting really down on herself for being one card down that she still has the rest of the week to make it up, and she normally does great so not to be too hard on herself, she was shocked - normally she would just be berated for that one single card. The managers don't even treat each other with respect - I got sick and called off for my first time in three years, and the AGM's words to me were "You have got to be kidding me!" and then when I apologized, a very sarcastic, "Yea, thanks!" and she hung up on me. This coming from an AGM who I have witnessed spend four hours sitting in the office playing on her cell phone, and who booksellers have told me many times avoids being on the floor as much as possible. I also find it frustrating that the company sets metrics goals, then makes them harder to reach. When I first started with BAM three years ago, the discount card expectation was 5% so you needed to sell a card for every $500 you had in sales. The card was $20, members got 10-40% off, weekly coupons, free express shipping, etc. Right around Christmas last year, they raised the price of the card to $25. This might not seem like much, but when we were a small mall store literally right across the street from a giant Barnes and Noble, being able to mention that our membership was $5 less than theirs was a great incentive. Shortly after, our goal was raised to 5.2%, supposedly so they could lower the goal at Christmas time and take some of the pressure off. Yea, right. Now you need to sell a card for every $425 or so in sales. Did I mention that they also took away the express part of the free shipping? And that there was no notice to customers about these changes, except for what the booksellers could tell them. I bought my own membership (Borders gave employees free members cards even when they started their own paid membership, by the way... not going to toot the Borders horn all things considered, but experiencing the benefits sure made it easier to talk about!) and had signed up for the auto-renewal. There was no notice about the fact that this year, my credit card was going to be charged $25 instead of $20, something that I really feel the company had an obligation to tell its customers, especially since to get the auto-renewal, you HAVE to provide an e-mail address, so a simple e-mail being sent out would have done the trick. Another issue: each store is an island. My original store was in northwestern Pennsylvania. Last year, we had no heat for the entire month of February. The company employs an online reporting system for various IT and maintenance and inventory issues, but they will really drag their feet the second there is anything that involves them shelling out some money to fix. Broken door that is so hard to close, my GM and I stopped letting our regular employees do it because people were literally hurting themselves on it? Three months before we got it 'fixed,' and that was only after daily phone calls to check on the progress and a strongly-worded e-mail that highlighted such things as 'lawsuit,' 'loss prevention,' and 'workers comp.' Even then, they would rather stick a band-aid on things than actually fix it, which means that a few months later, we're dealing with the same problem and beating our heads against the same wall trying to get workable conditions for our employees. We frequently felt like we were just on our own to make things work (we'd bring in our own fans/heaters to cope with thermostat issues, borrowed buckets when we had roof leaks, etc.) Need more shelves because they keep sending you more product than you have room for? Good luck. Want to carry local titles in your Pennsylvania store instead of the Alabama titles they keep sending you? Better special order them under a fake name, cause if you try to place an order for a book signing, school reading list, etc. that is not part of what the company expects you'll sell, they'll just cancel your order after taking four months to even acknowledge that you placed it. But make sure you switch up the names you use for these orders, because you will get yelled at for doing it even though you tried to go the proper venues and got zero results. tl;dr -not nearly enough compensation for the crap you have to deal with -management is forced and encouraged to treat employees like crap -company takes away benefits of the card but expects employees to sell more of them. -stores receive little to no support and assistance from corporate even for urgent needs like having heat in the middle of winter

2.0
Nov 7, 2018

Don't work for this company.

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Many of my coworkers have been genuinely kind and easy to work with. The bookstore environment is pleasant and, especially if you are a reader, it is satisfying to help customers find books they're looking for and even recommend titles for them.

Cons

If you have worked any retail job, you are aware that an associate position will come with many negative experiences with customers. That is par for the course for any customer service position. However, this company has severely restricted the capabilities of the sales associates, meaning that the likelihood of the customer becoming upset is increased. The store’s prices are higher than the prices on the Books A Million website. This means that you will often have to tell customers that, in fact, you do not match the prices of your own website. As a sales associate, you will not be able to perform a return; you will need a manager. Returns themselves are laborious processes that can take up to ten minutes to complete; and you are required to take down all the personal information of the customer, including their street address. Needless to say, many people do not wish their personal information to be taken down by every store they visit. As for the expectations of the job itself, to begin with, you are required to sell a barely-worth it $25 membership card to customers, as well as a set of three magazine subscriptions disguised as a risk-free trial offer (the intent for which is clear; the customer will forget to cancel their subscription and will be quietly billed without notification). Despite receiving minimal training for this, it became clear very early that this was the MOST important part of this position. The store operates on a week-to-week goal for membership cards/magazine subscriptions, and because of this, there is a constant threat of the store not reaching its goal — a PERPETUAL, unending crisis. The management, who all appear frightened by their overseers, are forced to reinvent their strategies for selling these magazine subscriptions (which are then translated into uninspiring pep-talks to the sales associates), as if it is their fault that customers do NOT WANT these magazines. The bulk of the magazine subscriptions our store made were when teenagers would use their parents’ credit card to buy something — and fall for the “free magazines” pitch. Many angry phone calls have been received by parents who found bank charges after letting their child use their card at Books A Million. Despite this constant pressure to perform as a salesman, this is a minimum wage position. Your “commission” for selling membership cards and magazine subscriptions are as follows: .16 cents per magazine, and .50 cents per membership card (no extra commission for convincing the customer to enroll in an automatic-renewal for their membership). If you think this sounds low, it’s because it is, and most of the time you won’t receive it, as your commission is reliant on THE ENTIRE STORE reaching its goal. Yes, that means that if you manage to reach, or even exceed, all of your sales goals for the week, you will most likely not receive any commission because the other sales associates haven’t met their goals. As a top performing salesman at my store, I sold at least 5 times as many subscription cards and magazines as my coworkers, and still rarely received any commission. Also, being a top performer, I was often expected by management to carry the entire store in order to reach its goal. And on the off chance that I had a day in which my numbers were lower, I was asked to explain why I didn’t sell as many membership cards and magazine subscriptions as usual (most often in a scolding or whiny tone). These are petty guilt trips, plain and simple.

1.0
Apr 25, 2015
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Just a word of caution before I begin. The 'Featured Review' does not line up at all with my, nor many other current/past employees, experience at South Portland's BAM. I don't know who wrote that review but if I had to guess it would probably be one of the full timers who got in good with management and/or don't normally work at the registers often. They would likely have a much more different perspective if this was not the case. The majority of workers there are simply not that privileged, and to call the people who left that job 'high maintenance' points to them having an unreasonably high expectation for the stress that a low-paying retail job should require or having high expectations for themselves. It seems unnervingly cookie cutter in that it sound more like a PR statement from corporate than an authentic review of one's experience here. The fact that it has a response from the Vice President of Human Relations is also an eye-brow raiser. But then again this is all simply my opinion, and whether those of you reading this agree or not is your own choice to make. Now to the actual Pros: 30% off employee discount. Essentially brought our store's product down to the the price of many online outlets. After sales tax the price was negligible. But it is still there and I've seen many associates get a good deal if the purchase is a big one. Could check out books for up to 2 weeks, but had to buy them if management found they where not in sellable condition. The scheduling is hit or miss. You could be working 6 days straight and then have 3 days off, or be working for two days a day off then working the rest of the week into the weekend, etc. One thing I will say is that management was always willing to work the best they could to fit your availability. A few managers where always willing to help, and give encouragement, the majority where not or did so in passive aggressive- or not so helpful ways. Strong associate team work. Many of us got together like we where family. I always saw others giving each other rides or sharing snacks in the break room/ etc. Whenever one of us was feeling down or over stressed I would see more seasoned associates help them out or console them. Overall a nice strong-nit team! Probably the best I've seen during my time in retail.

Cons

Long hours for little pay. Just like any other retail position. Except we are also required to be salesmen constantly pushing discount cards over and over. Getting called out on the radio and having reports printed out right in front of us at the register. Giving unneeded and unnecessary stress to an already stressful job. If management begins to see your card sales are lacking they will begin to cut hours drastically. I've seen some good employees get cut from 28 to 14 hours because of this. employees who have made strong connections with customers and actually had them coming back and generating business. I had to explain to these customers the many times they came in as they looked on with confused faces that Associate 'SoAndSo' wasn't in today and they'd reply that they hadn't seen them in a while. It got to the point were we where told in groups by management that if card sales did not go up the offenders would be fired. When I left it had gotten so bad that there was peer pressure between associates and a growing resentment between staff and management. Those who where bad at selling cards would already start their shift anxious and stressed while those who are good sellers know that they will have to carry the store throughout the day to keep management off our backs. Who are then scratching their heads as to why they have 4 employees quit in 2 weeks time, some not even giving 2 weeks notice, or the good sellers end up being fired/transferred because of shady business practices to meet their sales goal. New hires are called in the same day for orientation, unaware of the long nights of anxiety and ridicule they are signing up for, and they cycle continues. Need to mention we also given a bonus at the end of the week if we meet our weekly card goal. During my near half a year there I've only seen that happen twice. It is a joke at 8 dollars and hour to see maybe 7-10 dollars added to the end of my paycheck. Not really worth the effort if my job wasn't threatened. Customer service seems to be the last thing on the list for the majority of the store, second was recovery, and first was always the card! And if it wasn't about the card directly it would be brought right back around to it. Customer service was supposed to lead to a card recommendation, instead of just being friendly and helping the customer, we were also encouraged to go on about the 10% off and 'Oh we can get you free shipping online' etc. More often then not this would lead to an irritated customer who would then get further irritated at checkout as the bookseller up there would desperately try and push the card. I've had many customers display anger at this constant badgering as it is both annoying for repeat customers who aren't interested and the usual walk-in who just wants to get in and out fast. Huge lines are made due to the sales pitches we have to make, another common complaint I get when they finally get to me at the register. Overall no-one envies those stuck with a register. Management for the most part stays in the back office, only coming out to authorize returns. Of the few rare time's I've seen them with a till they themselves go against their own warnings and teachings. I.E. not asking every customer if they have a card, not pushing it three times, not going over everything etc. Of course they're not going to get called out of the radio, or corrected, or have their hours cut. Cafe is not much better. Few associates are trained to work shifts there, and we are STILL required to sell cards as well as maintain the large cafe lounge, and open/close on our own regardless if another barista is on staff to help make things easier. You will often find yourself at the end of your ship scrambling to get everything done within the last hour of your shift. Last bit about the cards: We are still, even if we do our job as salesmen correctly, setting ourselves up for failure as corporate wants at least near half of all discount cards sold to have auto renewal effectively making our ability to score that customer when they come back as a renew(and therefore a new card) moot and hurting our weekly card sales goal. For every card with auto renewal we sell the day before, we are expected to get the same amount if not more the next day. There are only so many cards we can sell at once, let alone without the customers who are already members with auto renew being locked out from us. Give your associates a break! Members sales still count towards your card percentage, you are still expected to meet your sales goal regardless of if you have 50 customers with auto-renew and 2 who have no card but didn't sign up.

Viewing 1 - 3 of 1,746 Reviews

Glassdoor has 1,784 Books-A-Million reviews submitted anonymously by Books-A-Million employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Books-A-Million is right for you.