Protiviti reviews

3.7

72% would recommend to a friend

(4,193 total reviews)
avatar

Joseph A. Tarantino

82% approve of CEO

56% positive business outlook

Protiviti has an employee rating of 3.7 out of 5 stars, based on 4,193 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Protiviti employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Management & Consulting industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

4K reviews
4.0
May 12, 2016

Tremendous firm that does terrible work

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

-Collegial and caring culture with a big emphasis on socializing/networking -Bright and friendly colleagues who are largely laid back and easy to work with -Transparent, approachable, and highly accessible senior management -Impressive portfolio of clients given the firm's size and age, particularly in the financial services, retail, and technology industries. -Excellent PTO benefits with employees starting at 20 days per year -Great work-life balance for consulting (I typically worked about 45 hours per week)

Cons

-Biggest con with Protiviti is the work itself. The vast majority of projects are internal audit or compliance related which is not the type of work that bright, motivated people in "consulting" want to do. Projects are rife with absurd grunt work which is tedious, boring, and frustrating all at the same time. The firm is trying hard to diversify its solution offerings into more true management consulting work, but the pace of change isn't quick enough for many. -The firm wants to position itself as a premier consulting provider, but refuses to spend like one. Practice employees are forced to perform ridiculous amounts of administrative project work because the firm's infrastructure is lacking and support employees in functions like practice management, finance, accounting, marketing, and travel are minimal. The firm also pushes worthless certifications over MBAs. Proprietary research/market databases and other tools you would expect of a top-tier consulting firm are also non-existent. -Brand recognition continues to lack in the marketplace which can be frustrating. Despite its success, the firm hasn't invested much in large-scale branding or marketing efforts, which I believe to be a mistake. Sponsoring dinners and conferences only gets you so far. -Promotions are basically guaranteed every two years. This is great for those who deserve it, but it also means that there are a lot of unimpressive people (with no experience except internal audit) in management positions.

avatar
Protiviti Response
9y
Thank you for your feedback. We agree that our people are one of the best aspects of working at Protiviti, and we are glad that you enjoyed our unique culture while you worked here! With regards to the type of work that we do, while internal audit is certainly a huge component of our business, we continue to explore other areas within business and technology risk to diversify our solution offerings. As a growing firm, we are also investing in our infrastructure and taking ongoing actions such as rolling out a new financial system that will ease administrative burdens. We remain focused on building a strong team that will enhance our culture as we grow. Again, thank you for your feedback, and best of luck on your future endeavors.
1.0
Jul 22, 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

I was an intern at this company during college and it truly was an awesome experience. They fly you out to Disney for training and really roll out the red carpet. The interns that they select are typically very social and like minded about work hard but play harder. As an intern you were staffed on what my managers called "sexy projects" that involved IPOs, fun client companies, and weekly intern bonding events with lots of food and alcohol. I was definitely drinking the Protiviti Kool-aid by the end of the internship.

Cons

After my internship experience I signed my full time offer thinking that I would have a great career and be able to learn new things and challenge myself. I was very excited. I quickly realized that the internship experience was not at all indicative of the real experience that I would have in this company. While I can only speak for the Dallas office and for the IAFA business solution, I believe that the Dallas Office as a whole is a sinking ship that bleeds talent due to the way that their upper level managers and HR team treats employees. Within the first month of starting, their whole BPI team (marketed as management consulting) jumped ship and left the company with the BPI Managing Director, not only that, but the Managing Director for the Technology Consulting solution at Protiviti Dallas also left the company. After about 7 months in, more than 20 people quit from all levels in the company including Consultants, Seniors, and Managers. I hope these numbers illustrate the type of negative workplace that Protivit Dallas is. In regards to the work itself, Dallas is mainly focused on Internal Audit, with more than 70% of their employees being hired into that solution. Lateral moves into different solutions is nearly impossible. I was also recruited to be in the FSI (Financial Services Industry) group as a IAFA "consultant" and was promised that I would see work involving modeling and capital markets but that was not the case. It was just a pitch to get an unassuming and naive college graduate to sign a letter of employment. Do not believe any of the recruiters when they tell you that you will be doing "Management consulting," and do not believe them when you are told that you will be exposed to different types of work. You will be sitting in a client office anywhere in the DFW metroplex (Fort Worth, Dallas, Las Colinas, Plano, Lewisville, Frisco) and you will be in a cubicle doing internal audit controls testing. Maybe you may get lucky every once and a while and be able to "travel" to West Texas. You will be doing Internal Audit process and control testing until you either quit the company or become a Manager. As an IAFA consulting I received virtually 0 experience and my accounting/finance knowledge actually regressed from college. I highly encourage anyone who is young, ambitious, and has an interest in higher level accounting and finance to avoid working here unless it is the only option. You will not work with Financial Statements, you will not gain valuable excel experience, you will not learn anything specific except about how processes and controls work for different companies. In regards to recruiting, the college recruiter was very aggressive and tried to get those of us who completed the internship to sign immediately. After speaking with my college advisors who have an agreement with Protiviti, the HR team allowed us much more time and quit hounding us to sign. In regards to work-life balance Protiviti is much better than the Big 4 accounting firms in regards to their respective Audit teams. There is no busy season and typically you work from 8 to ~5:30. That being said, attending company events is mandatory and tied into your bonus incentives. If you do not attend after hour events or get involved in their different company groups you will be penalized financially (in terms of bonus eligibility) and viewed as a disloyal employee. This will ultimately affect your ability to be staffed as HR keeps a note of who is involved and who isn't and will punish you accordingly. I found HR to be very dishonest and nontransparent. They are in charge of staffing you on projects and love to staff people who they dislike on bad projects with long commutes or defunct leadership to push you out of the company. The benefits are also very bad, and many employees will tell you to try to get insurance coverage through a spouse or family member. Other than that, I found that many of the managers, especially in the FSI team, are extremely toxic and expect you to put your own time to do more work on the weekends. I was told to put more hours in without billing the client and was also told to study up on SEC banking regulations on my own time and give weekly progress reports to an MD. Needless to say I left the company and am now employed with a firm that values my needs and provides me the tools/experience I need to be successful and grow.

5.0
Mar 5, 2015
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Significantly improved work-life balance. Competitive salary and incentive structure. Company culture is hands down the best I've experienced. A truly collaborative organization filled with smart people who genuinely care about the professional growth of their peers and want to help each other. It almost sounds too good to be true - but in actuality, this firm is peaking. With earnings as high as they've ever been in 2014, and the company making its mark in Fortune 100's Best Companies to Work For list (albeit, #100 is "last place" but let's put into perspective just how young this company is and how quickly it ended up on this prestigious list for the first time since the company's inception).

Cons

Hopefully, this streak of winning will continue for as long as possible. For now, I am enjoying the ride and re-invigorated with a new energy for my career - a certain spark that I felt when I first started out as a Big 4 consultant... only to see it quickly fade away and drown out in a sea of office politics, unclear performance review standards, two-faced management, subpar compensation/incentives, and broken career promises (i.e. "sure we'll try to staff you on XYZ project <or something that better aligns with your interests>... just stick it out with current ABC project <or something that is in demand and needs more bodies ASAP> for another year.") Some of these qualities are inevitable when it comes to consulting firms, and I'd be lying if I said Protiviti was an exception. However, what makes this firm awesome is that these are kept to the bare minimum. The firm continues to make a CLEAR effort to listen to its employees and REACT to the feedback provided, so that working here is a POSITIVE EXPERIENCE.

avatar
Protiviti Response
10y
Thank you taking the time to provide your experiences at Protiviti! I appreciate the shout-out to our recruiting team and I'm so glad that you've had great experiences working with them! It's a fantastic group who cares genuinely about ensuring they find the right fit for both the firm and the candidate. We are absolutely keeping our eye on efficiencies we can continue to build within our team as we continue to grow. Stay tuned for more information about our new experienced hire onboarding program that we just piloted in San Francisco last week!
Viewing 1 - 3 of 4,193 Reviews

Glassdoor has 5,034 Protiviti reviews submitted anonymously by Protiviti employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Protiviti is right for you.