Selective Insurance employees working as Analyst in US have attributed a compensation and benefits rating of 1.3 out of 5 stars, based on 3 ratings. This is in line with the average of Analyst professionals at Selective Insurance worldwide.
The salary trajectory of a Analyst ranges between locations and employers. The salary starts at $108,934 per year (estimate) and goes up to $277,413 per year (estimate) for the highest level of seniority.
The estimated average salary for a Analyst at Selective Insurance is $108,940 per year or $52 per hour, but some professionals have reported earning up to roughly $181,661 per year (90th percentile). The typical pay range is between $83,937 (25th percentile) and $143,231 (75th percentile) annually. This is based on 4 salaries submitted by Selective Insurance Analyst professionals on Glassdoor, as of Jun 2026.
Analyst professionals typically earn between $40 and $69 per hour.
Analyst professionals typically earn between $6,995 and $11,936 monthly.
Analyst with an estimated total pay of $74K - $117K/yr