employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

Selective Insurance

Engaged Employer

Selective Insurance reviews

2.7

32% would recommend to a friend

(21 total reviews)
avatar

John Marchioni

41% approve of CEO

37% positive business outlook

Reviews by job title

21 reviews

Reviews about "Diversity & Inclusion"

Return to all reviews
1.0
May 26, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Decent benefits and decent coworkers

Cons

Working at Selective was a toxic work environment shaped by favoritism, excessive workload expectations, and poor boundaries around employee availability. Management often applied expectations unevenly, which created a lack of fairness and accountability. High performance did not always seem to be the primary factor in decision-making, which undermined trust in leadership. There was also a strong “big fish, small pond” dynamic, where internal status and informal influence often carried more weight than actual performance or collaboration. This contributed to a highly political environment where trust between colleagues was limited and information did not always feel safe to share openly. Employees were expected to be available far beyond normal working hours, creating an unsustainable “always on” culture with no real work-life balance. The workload was consistently too high for the compensation provided. Internal politics further interfered with day-to-day work and made collaboration more difficult than it needed to be. In practice, this environment often encouraged self-preservation over teamwork, which made it difficult to build trust or rely on others consistently. Overall, the environment was not structured in a way that supported long-term employee wellbeing or retention. This is not a workplace that supports a healthy work-life balance. For me, the experience felt unsustainable, and over time it became clear that the environment was not conducive to long-term growth or wellbeing.

1.0
Feb 25, 2026

Declining Culture and Lack of Clear Remote Work Policy or Equitable Practices

Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Mid-level leaders are working hard to protect their teams and maintain morale, even when executive decisions make that difficult. Strong peer commiseration across teams to help each other cope.

Cons

The company has undergone significant changes that have negatively impacted morale and trust in leadership. The CEO appears disconnected from the day-to-day realities employees face, particularly regarding work-life balance and commuting expectations. With the relocation from Branchville to Short Hills, many long-tenured employees are being placed in a difficult position. Unlike senior executives, most employees cannot easily afford to move closer to the new office location. The shift to increased in-office requirements feels less like a collaboration-driven initiative and more like a strategy that disproportionately impacts established team members. Work-life balance has significantly eroded. At a time when many peer organizations are adopting thoughtful hybrid and remote strategies to attract and retain talent, this company is moving in the opposite direction. This approach will likely create substantial turnover and make it challenging to fill the many roles that will become vacant. Additionally, there are inequitable practices surrounding remote work. There is no clearly defined or consistently applied remote work policy, leading to confusion and perceptions of favoritism. Expectations vary by team and individual, which undermines fairness and transparency.

1.0
Nov 8, 2024
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

There are not a lot of positives with Selective Insurance

Cons

Toxic work environment, managers that have no clue what they are doing. There's a level of Micromanagement that occurs if you challenge anything out of the norm. Its your typical 1970's insurance company, no diversity, no diversity in thought. I had a couple of incidents with a toxic, power hungry manager that treated me different than other employees. I went to HR and they were dismissive and non-existent. Often your HR rep would change sometimes monthly, so there was really no support from HR. I went to Senior Leadership with my issues about being treated differently and Senior Leadership basically told me to be quiet. This company truly is awful, its like working in a prison.

Viewing 1 - 3 of 21 Reviews

Glassdoor has 490 Selective Insurance reviews submitted anonymously by Selective Insurance employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Selective Insurance is right for you.